It’s been a while since I’ve been on the political soapbox, but I found that Paul Krugman’s recent editorial put its finger on something I’ve been thinking, but haven’t quite been able to put into words. I’ve spoken often on this blog about the dumbing down of America, but somewhere along the way the Republicans institutionalized this trend and capitalized on it. Key quote:
“…know-nothingism — the insistence that there are simple, brute-force, instant-gratification answers to every problem, and that there’s something effeminate and weak about anyone who suggests otherwise — has become the core of Republican policy and political strategy. The party’s de facto slogan has become: “Real men don’t think things through.”
Most of our current problems: the housing bubble, our deteriorating infrastructure, our dependence on foreign oil, the war in Iraq, the looming Social Security and Medicare crises, the debt position of most familes, and other issues are all borne of the inability to think long term through complex interwoven issues. My parents’ generation was steeped in the ideology that sacrifice now for greater good later was the key to a good life. Most religious ideology has similar roots (although you usually have to die for your reward to come), but the idea of sowing now to reap later is core to most faiths. Are we so self-absorbed as a generation that we can’t see the implications of our short-term pay-me-now philosophy on our children and grandchildren?
If something looks to good to be true, it probably is. That’s why Lipozene won’t make you thin, why playing Lotto doesn’t count as a retirment strategy, why drilling for more oil off the coast doesn’t solve our energy issues, and why kicking Saddam’s butt doesn’t make the Mid-East more stable.
I don’t think for a minute that Obama has all the answers, but I’m encouraged that he seems to believe that progress is incremental and sometimes painful. I also worry that a likely bi-cameral majority of Democrats with a Democratic White House will yield a different but equally destructive unchecked reign of government. But at this point the Republicans are acting like children and haven’t shown the maturity of judgement required to lead. I miss the pre-Reagan G.O.P., the one that was truly fiscally conservative, the one that was interested in nation-building in our own country. It balanced the Democrats’ socialism and provided true choice. But not anymore.
I’d like to blame the Republicans for the slide into the “Me Generation” abyss, but I can’t. They are victims of their own success. As a nation, we buy Lipozene and Lotto tickets, and we elect politicians who sell the idea that each of us can be better than average. We respond to the sound bite. We don’t think things through. There was a time when politicians appealed to the best of. Asking us to ask what we can do for our country. Inspiring us to be better as a group than maybe we thought we were individually. But now they appeal to our baser instincts. They divide and conquor. They ask us to be better to ourselves than to the nation as a whole. And unfortunately they succeed with that strategy.
How does this change? Only when we change. If we buy it, they will sell it, not the other way around. Think things through, or at least follow those who you believe do. Don’t fall for what makes you feel good. Don’t take the easy way out. Recognize that progress is hard work and requires sacrifice. Accept that half of us will always be below average. Inspire. Aspire. Perspire.
I certainly agree with the effect, but I’m not so sure of the cause. I think the dumbing down of the GOP has more to do with the influence of the religious right than the effects of instant gratification on society. Isn’t Bush’s arrogance a mirror of the RR’s? The “things are simple and I know I’m right” approach? Or is it more of a “We’ll do God’s will and He/She will take care of the rest.” strategy? Bush himself has never been about instant gratification… “Stay the course.”, “there’s a lot of hard work ahead”. I’m working from memory here, but I think he said those things about Iraq.
Both parties suffer the ill effects of a me first society, but only one has the faith to see it through.
Brian
That’s an interesting point Brian. Bush certainly has said things to the effect of there being a lot of hard work ahead. But initially the Iraq War was sold to the public as a quick fix. We’d be home and safe in 6 months.
I’m trying to recall if there was any sort of “stay the course” or “long hard road” rhetoric prior to the Iraq debacle. For that matter, has he tried to sell anything else that way? Social Security was going to be fixed by a painless and quick privatization. Fixing the economy was just a matter of taking off the brakes (regulations) and lowering the taxes. Education was simply a matter of more testing and bigger sticks for failing the tests.
I do agree that the RR is more than a little prone to the simplistic view of the world. That’s one of the reasons they’ll never buy into science as it’s really complicated. It’s a lot simpler to just say God did it and intended it to be this way.
But I wonder, was the RR drawn to the Republicans because they share the simplistic world-view? Or did the Republicans start pitching simplicity to appeal to the RR demographic? My guess would be that this was a sort of self-reinforcing feedback loop that evolved over time.
Also, as you note, the “me generation” is not a construction of the RR. It’s way more pervasive than that. And I think that while the RR may have the simplistic world view thing down to an art, that’s much broader than them as well.